Sex determination in mammals is highly conserved, with males being heterogamous (XY) and females being homogamous (XX). However, several rodent species exhibit aberrant sex determination in which some females have an XY karyotype. Among these species, members of the genus Akodon are especially unique because XY females appear to be the consequence of a disfunctional Y chromosome (rather than a mutant X). Maintenance of such XY females in natural populations presents a substantial evolutionary puzzle because simple population genetics models predict that such a chromosome would be lost from a population within only a few generations. We will present a series of simple population genetics models in which the potential influence of different evolutionary forces are assayed. The results of these simulations will be used to prioritize likely mechanisms, and to construct hypotheses for more focussed field-based studies.